This headband is identical to the first one I made except for the edging (and lining color -- but it's the same brand and weight of yarn). This time I crocheted the lining and outer fabric together. It makes a neater finish, and I like the look of the crochet -- it reminds me of fancy piped frosting on a birthday cake.
But. It makes a much tighter fit. If I make this style again, I'll have to find a stretchier crochet stitch.
Ironically enough, it's too icy outside to put these headbands to use walking the dogs. Guess I'll have to make another headband!